By Olivia Hunt, Community Editor
Out of spontaneous interest, I have been reading Lena Dunham’s memoir Famesick (2025), during which she mentions Noah Baumbach pretty often as her ‘good friend’ and specifically notes that one of the final sequences in Baumbach’s Frances Ha (2012) was actually filmed in her apartment after they’d finished the first season of Girls (2012-2017).
This grants a new self-reflexivity to the ending of the film. Frances (Greta Gerwig - Baumbach’s wife and muse who also co-write the script with him), finally clicks into motion and prioritises herself and her art, instead of trailing behind Sophie (Mickey Sumner) in the same space where Dunham broke into the iconic success of Girls.
Baumbach excels at depicting relationships in the epicentre of New York, committing to the trials of friendship and finding work amidst chaos whilst staying protective of art. Marriage Story (2019) - his most successful film to date - has the exact right balance of this, featuring a broken relationship that clings to heart-breaking sequences of a child caught in the middle of his parents’ crumbling marriage. Interactions with the lawyers and therapists provide comic relief but are filtered by melancholic effect. The line between comedy and tragedy is so close and so effective.
The opening sequence, during which Charlie (Adam Driver) and Nicole (Scarlett Johansson) both read out things they love about each other to a therapist over a montage of moments in their relationship (which we find out they never expressed out loud) has always stuck in my mind. We learn of their tarnished relationship to each other and their relationships to theatre and art, being actor and director. Baumbach’s script is beautifully poignant but unsettling as you learn to both sympathise with and dislike both of the characters really early on.
This same theme also links to Baumbach’s uncovering of female friendships in Frances Ha. Frances initially sets her life as codependent to her best friend/room-mate Sophie but learns that prioritising herself and her art is more significant. Whilst Sophie excels in having a ‘proper’ job and finding a husband (which we find is not so simple), Frances works on her dancing and eventually lives in a flat alone. Even though she is deemed ‘undateable’ by Benji (Michel Zegen), a previous house-mate, you really grow to love her character even when she is being childish and trivial.

In Mistress Americana (2015), Baumbach and Gerwig collaboratively encounter a friendship that seems more transactional and calculated. Tracy (Lola Kirke) becomes obsessed with her new step-sister Brooke (Gerwig) as she tries to put together some creative writing based on Brooke for a literary society piece. The film is packed with comedic philosophical speculation and just pure fun! Being one of Baumbach’s lesser-known works, I really recommend it if you’re a fan of Frances Ha.
In an interview promoting the film, Gerwig spoke about the joy she had in writing Brooke’s character, saying that ‘she is a mouth-piece for anything crazy you’ve wanted to say […] she elevates everybody into her world’, which I feel is the same for other Baumbach characters; they’re silly, relatable and immersed in disorder but eventually find themselves.
Featured image: IMDb / Noah Baumbach
What’s your favourite Noah Baumbach film?
