Skip to content

Primetime: A compelling criticism of trial by television

Robert Pattinson returns in Lance Oppenheim’s new film, whose resplendent and theatrical cinematography immerses the viewer in the tangible desperation of the entertainment industry, the obsession of performance, the fixation on personal significance and how capitalism amplifies the need to succeed.

By Luca Woodruff, Third Year, Law

From director Lance Oppenheim, Primetime (2026) follows American presenter Chris Hansen (Robert Pattinson) as his hidden-camera show To Catch a Predator (2004-2007) grows in popularity.

Before anything else, we see Hansen rehearsing lines in a shadowed dressing room, memorising lascivious messages from the latest predator. And a few minutes later, he is in a recording studio, obsessing over his line delivery to a comic degree. There is a slyness to Pattinson’s performance; a garish arrogance which, coupled with his cartoonish vocal impression, is certainly a standout of his career.

Oppenheim depicts Hansen not as a journalist but a performer. He draws a comparison between the presenter and the newest ‘decoy’, Dan Plumb (Skyler Gisondo), by intertwining their narratives throughout the film’s duration. Plumb describes himself as a ‘professionally trained actor’: a repeated claim which only reveals his desperation to be taken seriously. Like Hansen, there are numerous scenes where Plumb studies other actors or his own performance to improve his craft. When placed side by side, there is an obvious similarity in their drive to be recognised.

Alongside its examination of performance, Primetime confronts the presentation of justice. In the first sting operation, Hansen asks the predator what he thinks should happen to him. ‘The electric chair?’, the man timidly replies. The aim of the show is not to open conversations of rehabilitation or psychological understanding: it is solely about punishment. But Oppenheim suggests this appetite for violent justice is shared by the audience. When a fan asks the presenter if he ever just wants to ‘bleed ‘em’, Hansen argues that what he does ‘is a little worse’.

Hansen is clearly aware of how his show imitates justice through humiliation. Meanwhile, the real justice system is nowhere to be found. A policeman, a fan of Hansen’s work, is played as an idiot and an image of institutional failure. The entertainment industry is purporting to fill this vacuum of justice, making television the vigilante and ‘saving children’ its mission. Primetime asks an important question: is this show doing what the authorities are failing to?

It should not be immediately dismissed. After all, intercepting child sexual predators and sending many of them to prison is a worthy cause. But Oppenheim seems to be placing less focus on the effects of Hansen’s work and more on the intention behind it. Although To Catch a Predator might appear to enforce justice, its true form is a spectacle of punishment. 

Intention, then, is what the narrative seems to hinge on, and, for all the major characters, this is about personal success. Andie Bender, the producer of the show, is played to perfection by Merritt Wever. With a patronising compassion, Wever’s Andie is calculated and cold; she is a businesswoman with little time for sentiment. Like Chris, Andie’s only consideration is her most practical path to success, ultimately declaring she can ‘make this work’ when the final predator commits suicide.

Similarly threaded through the film is Plumb’s audition, during which he performs ‘Seasons of Love’ from the stage musical Rent, which follows a group of artists as they struggle to afford to live in New York City. The song bookends the narrative, playing early on and again in the final scene. Its significance is clear: to emphasise desperation under capitalism and how individuals sacrifice parts of themselves in the securing their livelihoods.

Oppenheim is careful about what he accuses Hansen of. Although the film documents his affair and marital collapse, Hansen is not equated to the men he exposes. However, he is shown to be self-righteous and desperate to establish his own significance. This is best observed in the scene in which Hansen warns Plumb of an ‘ancient evil’: a shadow-lurking monster we see in both a flashback and the final scene. It is a manifestation of what Hansen is seeking out in his work. But there is no ‘ancient evil’ and, in imagining one, Hansen is casting himself as the force of good which works against it. It is a gross oversimplification and one which gratifies the believer that, since they are not evil, they must be on the side of good.

The 2027 Oscars: Is a big sweep on the cards?
At the beginning of the 2026/27 awards season, Bethan Parry-Jones tests the water and sees what films could be contending for Hollywood's biggest honour.

Primetime’s only shortcoming is its failure to comment on the audience, who embody the cultural behaviour behind the show’s popularity. There are frequent shots where we become the viewer, voyeuristically observing from behind a pixelated screen, making the absent audience commentary starker. In retelling such a dramatic escalation of events - where we are eventually dealing with suicide – why should we not investigate the bloodlust of the public? If the ratings and viewership are of such abundance for a show which glorifies humiliation and satisfies a social desire for retribution, there must exist a cultural sadism which explains the appetite for legitimised violence. 

Regardless of this omission, Oppenheim poses a captivating criticism of trial by television. Justice staged as entertainment cannot replace the judicial process because its only measure of success is how satisfying the punishment is to watch. Primetime is not asking whether predators deserve punishment, rather eliciting us to question what we become when we enjoy it.

Featured image: IMDb / Primetime


What did you think of Primetime?

Latest