Skip to content

Are black people allowed to fail?: The pressure of ‘Black excellence’

Leigh reflects on Professor Arday’s passing, exploring how the concept of ‘Black excellence’ is harmful for Black students

By Leigh Mendes, Second Year, Politics and International Relations

Standing in the centre of Senate House or walking into a lecture hall in the Arts Complex, it does not take long to do the maths. At the University of Bristol, where around 75 per cent of domestic students are white-British, being a Black student means I am almost always in the minority. I have learnt quickly what it it feels like to stand out. And, with that comes an unspoken and heavy mantle: the expectation to achieve ‘Black excellence’.

The anxiety Black excellence causes 

To many, ‘Black excellence’ is an empowering desire to succeed, professionally and personally. It represents the ability to overcome historical disadvantages, rising above tired stereotypes of unprofessionalism and deprivation. But there is a much darker reality. For many, ‘Black excellence’ is not merely an aspiration, but a condition of entry. A lingering belief that we must be exceptional just to be seen as equal. 

When exceptionalism becomes the baseline, failure stops being an option. My white peers are given room for growth and second chances, whilst other Black students and I feel that we are held to a zero-margin-for-error standard. 

The consequences of ‘Black excellence’ within higher education

The fatal consequences of this standard made themselves evident with Professor Jason Arday’s, the youngest Black professor in Cambridge’s history, unfortunate passing – exposing the brutal cost of institutional pressure. 

'When exceptionalism becomes the baseline, failure stops being an option' | Epigram / Leigh Mendes

Over twenty-two days, Jason was the subject of 249 articles across 15 national media outlets in the UK. Following intense public scrutiny and media coverage over academic biographical inaccuracies, Arday resigned and committed suicide shortly after. 

What happened to his white-counterparts, who committed similar, if not worse, offences than him? Professor Miles Hewstone at Oxford resigned while under investigation following allegations of sexual harassment and bullying, yet retained his ‘emeritus’ rank for years. Additionally, Nicola Morrison at Cambridge was allowed to keep her job after she was accused of plagiarism. 

Without dismissing the importance of academic integrity, the media trial surrounding Professor Arday exposed a glaring double standard. When white academics misstep, they are granted quiet resignations, or the luxury of redemption. But, when a Black figure falls off the pedestal of excellence, the same system that once glorified them as a ‘diversity trophy’ turns around to dismantle their humanity.

How this impacts Black students

This double standard directly shapes how we navigate their student life at Bristol. I spoke to another Black student, who opened up about the pressure to be exceptional at university: 

‘The standards for Black people are a lot higher. The moment we slip anything below one hundred, it's an issue.
I have to work twice as hard to get half as far. I don't get to sit down and play folly about not understanding something, because Bristol is fundamentally a white institution
To not perform well is almost a slight onto myself, my community and my parents
I’ve constantly had to placate myself and stipulate that ‘oh well Black people have these struggles’, but that’s not to say white people don’t have the same struggles too
That in itself is a way for me to make what I’m saying more digestible because the conversation around white fragility is one that quite frankly, a lot of people are not even ready for yet’

‘Black excellence’ is a dual trap: we must not only overcome systemic barriers to get through the door, but we are forced to sanitise our reality, so white peers and institutions remain comfortable. 

How accessible is Bristol for students with disabilities?
Erin Disney highlights the challenges disabled students face in Bristol; from social challenges to physical ones
The north-south divide in Bristol
Milly Middlehurst discusses how regional discrimination is mitigated by the university, and explores different responses to the sounds of the north.

We all need to question why society only celebrates Black individuals when they are pioneers or historic ‘firsts’. 

‘True equality can only be achieved when Black people are granted the ordinary, fundamental human right to be average, make mistakes, learn, and fail without facing systemic exile’

Without the freedom to make mistakes and learn from them, ‘Black excellence’ to me isn’t liberation – it’s an impossible standard. 

Featured Image: Epigram / Romina Trevino


Have you ever felt like a single mistake could ruin everything you’ve worked to build?

Latest